Verified Document

Human Learning Experimental Subjects Were Term Paper

Subjects in T2 and T3 were given forty-five minutes to complete their puzzles. At the beginning of the actual treatment, subjects in T2 and T3 were encouraged to ask for assistance if they needed any.

T2 subjects were given positive feedback from researchers even when negative feedback was warranted, such as being unable to complete the easy puzzle in forty-five minutes. Researchers were instructed to say encouraging, affirmative things to subjects even when subjects were having no problems with the puzzles, such as "You're making fine progress!" "Good job!" "I know you can do it!" "That's looking great!" And so forth. Further, researchers were instructed to make these comments loudly enough for them to be overheard by the most distant subject.

T3 subjects' researchers were instructed to give negative feedback at every opportunity, and to make opportunities if none presented themselves with comments such as "You should be smart enough to finish that puzzle at your age!" "I can't believe you're having this much trouble with this puzzle!" "The last class had already finished their puzzles by now!" "I guess you're just not good at puzzles, huh?" Again, researchers were instructed to make these comments loudly enough for all the subjects to hear them.

After the treatment, all groups were subjected to a thirty minute vocabulary lesson and given fifteen minutes to study silently. This study period was followed by collection of the puzzles from groups T2 andT3 and toys from T1.

Having their uncompleted puzzles collected reminded the T3s of how poorly they had performed. Having their completed puzzles collected reminded the T2s of how well they had performed.

At this point, all groups were given the test, which lasted for ten minutes and consisted of fill in the blank questions. A choice set of thirty words was included, which included the original vocabulary words plus fifteen distractors.

RESULTS

Analysis of variance was performed on all...

The results showed that positive feedback positively effected subjects' test scores relative to the control group and negative feedback negatively affected subjects' scores relative to the control group. However, the scale of the effect differed according to treatment; negative feedback had a more powerful influence on test scores than did positive feedback.
DISCUSSION

The discrepancy between the power of positive verses negative feedback to influence subjects' test scores warrants discussion. There is a stream of literature that has addressed the weights raters assign negative information verses positive information. It has shown that negative information is usually weighted more heavily than positive information, regardless of the context. More specifically, if an opinion leader conveys negative information about a product to someone, say a co-worker, almost no amount of praise from other opinion leaders regarding the same product can efface the damage done by the one negative comment. Sequence effects have been shown to be largely irrelevant, so whether the negative information comes before or after the praise has no bearing on how difficult it is to overcome the negative information's influence.

An argument could be made that something similar is going on here; there is just something about negativity that has a more powerful psychological influence on the receiver than positivity.

In any event, that positive feedback encourages learning and negative feedback discourages it has profound implications not only for pedagogy in general but for explaining (and potentially remedying) the apparent disparity between minority groups' test scores and the majority group's test scores. Whether a child's self-esteem is damaged by a parent, a teacher, or by society in general, the effect on his or her success in school and in life beyond academics depends, in a measurable way, on the extent of the damage.

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Experimental Critique You Have Just Answered an
Words: 1678 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Experimental Critique You have just answered an advertisement to participate in an experiment from researchers at Yale University. You enter a professional looking building and are met by a professional looking man in a white lab coat. You have been paid $4.50 (which would have easily filled up your gas tank in 1961) to participate in a memory and learning experiment. The experiment requires that you play the role of "teacher"

Human Aggression and the Stanford Prison Experiments
Words: 2535 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Human Aggression and the Stanford Prison Experiments Studies of human aggression tend toward myriad and often competing conclusions about that which drives us to behave ethically or unethically, about the forces that incline us toward altruism as opposed to those which incline us toward aggression, about the impulses to behave according to internal values and the pressures to bend to contextual authority. Perhaps few studies on the subject have penetrated the

Learning Motivation Learning and Motivation
Words: 3469 Length: 10 Document Type: Essay

') (Tingstrom et al., 226) in correspondence with the example provided by the researchers responsible for this evaluation, it may be deduced that such method of positive reinforcement implementation is best suited to a younger educational context such as grammar school. It may only be considered appropriate to attach the positive consequences of individual efforts with the capabilities of an entire class in settings where future prospects such as class

Brain-Based Learning Theory
Words: 4565 Length: 17 Document Type: Term Paper

Brain-Based Learning Theory Learning does not only bring enlightenment to the weary souls but it also helps us learn, grow and be what we are potentially able to become. Therefore education plays a vital role in inculcating a sense of responsibility in children and to assist them in learning other highly important social skills. Thus through adequate instructional framework and effective and logical application of the learning theories, both educators and

Psychology - Human Interaction the
Words: 1059 Length: 4 Document Type: Thesis

By that time, several guards had become sadistic and the behavior of the prisoners provided clear indications of psychological breakdown. Interviews with study participants suggested that merely the perception of their respective roles influenced their behavior. More importantly, the groupthink that prevailed within the group of prison guards overcame any individual personal reluctance they may have had to treat their prisoners so harshly (Macionis 2003). The Significance of the

Learning Organization. Consolidate Research Definitions Organization...
Words: 1402 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

learning organization. *Consolidate research definitions organization learning. *Explain organization a learning organization (teaching federal government hospital). *Discuss advantages disadvantages organizational learning. The learning organization The modern day business climate is more challenging and dynamic and it forces the economic agents to seek alternative sources of strategic advantages. One example in this sense is represented by the enhancement of the emphasis placed on supporting learning and the continuous development of the organization

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now